You're not going to buy an iPad.
Submitted by ipodgamer on Wed, 01/27/2010 - 20:58iPad is here, Steve jobs announced the new tablet device today as expected. The media hype surrounding this announcement has been absolutely huge. Twitter has been buzzing all day and the hashtags #iSlate, #iPad etc.. have been trending for much of it. But who is this device actually aimed at?
I have a laptop, a PC, a decent Phone, a 3rd gen iPod Touch, various next gen games consoles and other gaming handheld devices. Do I need an iPad? My head says no, my wallet says no and even the Apple geek in me says NO!
I expect that many other techie types are of the same opinion?
My major concern is for the iPads ability in it's current revision to function as a gaming device. Sure it will run iPhone native apps and games, but with the ommision of any physical buttons, how are gamers going to play on the iPad comfortably? While, the increase in screen real estate is more than welcome. It may result in native iPhone games running in either iPhone sized windows, or they will be blown up and horribly pixelated. Apple suggest that there is pixel technology in place to address the resolution issue. But whether it actually will remains to be seen.

I know that many devs are tripping over themselves to get apps optimised and published for the iPad platorm. Gameloft have suggested that NOVA will be amongst their first releases for the tablet. But whether developers target the system exclusively will depend on the uptake of the iPad and the demographic that buys it. What is this demographic? The suggestion that the iPad is a complimentary product to the Mac and the iPhone, is sheer folly. Nobody in their right mind will buy an iPad if they currently own a Mac Book pro and an iPhone surely? There are some other huge ommisions in the first revision for example..
iPad failures
- No true Multitasking, this is the biggest ommision, even a basic netbook can multitask, shame on you Apple!
- No Flash support, please don't start with the HTML5 argument! I am a professional developer and I know that HTML5 full support is still a long way off. If Apple are trying to push HTML5 this is not the way to do it. It's more likely that Flash is not included as a way to stop hulu and other flash based services from stealing users from iTunes.
- No camera, not really a deal breaker for most, but imagine what the iPad could be if it had a camera! it could become the ultimate multimedia, mobile web publishing device
I am also concerned regarding the iPads battery life, god knows my iPod touch starts whimpering in the corner after a few hours gaming. How would the battery be able to provide the juice requirements of a power hungry GPU and massive screen? Even 3 hours of mobile gaming seem unrealistic on the iPad.

For the time being I can't envision the average PS3, 360 gamer forking out for what is essentially an oversized iPod touch. I am not for a moment suggesting that, the iPad will never become a gaming device. It most probably will. But as with all Apple products, it really needs to go through a few generations before it's going to be anywher near ready. For the time being let the Apple fanboys be the beta testers and maybe check back this time next year!




Comments
What is it good for? Maybe some things...
Thu, 01/28/2010 - 21:20 — RustySabreOkay, I'll confess that I read the initial post and just a few snippets of the replies, so I'm sorry if this has already been covered. I think you've hit the nail on the head in your assessment that while a big screen is great, the aesthetics of the device are not conducive to gaming as a whole. People are still crying that the iPhone / iPod Touch could never be a real gaming device because of the lack of hardware buttons (I don't agree, mind you), and now you want me to accept a device that's at least twice as big and STILL doesn't have physical buttons? I barely came to grips (pun intended) with playing some games on my iPod; I can't even fathom playing them on the iPad. And what about games that cause you to constantly rotate your device more than 180 degrees? I think I'd end up breaking my wrists on the iPad :)
That being said, the iPad will be great for things like hidden object games, match 3 games and word games. In fact, puzzle games in general should really benefit from the larger screen. Also, any sort of turn based strategy game would be awesome on this device. The more I think about these types of games, the more I think I'd actually like to play around with an iPad. Unfortunately, since most of my "must play" games don't fall into these categories, that still leaves me with the need for two devices. As such, I think I'll stick with my iPod Touch for now.
Of course, if someone wanted to generously donate one to a dedicated and informative reviewer...
I Get that I Don't Get It
Thu, 01/28/2010 - 19:28 — yorkcountyflyerOn the day of Apple's big announcement, I confess to taking part in mocking the new iPad. But with a little time to process the news, I think I can finally forumlate a more mature response.
Although there is definitely something cool about the iPad, the new Apple gadget did not win me over instantly. Not like when the iPod Touch was unveiled. At that time, I saw a shiny new device that was nearly identitical to the iPhone and had all the features I wanted and needed. The high-quality display, easy music and video management, and perfect portability made this device an easy choice. The App Store and its convenient and affordable access to games was like an open invitation to the world. The quality of touch screen and accelerometor features along with high-end graphics and console like animation provided a rich playing experience that energized the entire gaming industry.
That said, there is certainly enough momentum generated by the iPhone/iPod Touch phenomenon to carry the iPad pretty far. But aside from the usual early adopters who love anything Apple produces, it's far too early to label the iPad as a game changer. One big question is who is going to buy this device? You may toss your Kindle aside but probably not your laptop or iPhone/iPod Touch. If early sales don't go well, will developers continue making apps specifically targeting the device? In my opinion, it's not the gadget but the momentum generated by an excited fan base that make it a successful product. People like their phones so it didn't take long to see iPhones in the wild, generating more interest with each sighting. Are we likely to see the same thing with the iPad?
There are certainly other questions. What is the need for this product? Are there particular demographics that the iPad will attract over another? Will gamers benefit the most or will it be people over 50 who normally need bifocals to read text messages on their iPhone? I really want to like the iPad. Unfortunately, I just don't see the practical need for it in my every day life. It seems like an extraneous purchase, which fails to eliminate any of the technology I already own. Since it can't replace my current laptop, it's hard to justify the cost of owning another device with features that are really more of a luxury than a necessity.
Despite my early skepticism, I do hope the iPad can push the limits of technology and challenge the existing paradigms we have about gaming. I'm not afraid of the inevitability that my iPod Touch will someday become obsolete. I hope the iPad can do for the gaming industry what the iPhone/iPod Touch has done in 2009. Prove me wrong. Prove it can spark another computer revolution and become the device everyone wants and needs. In the end, we benefit from product innovation and the competitive spirit that compels corporations to build a better mouse trap. I think I can speak for everyone at Touch iPhone Games when I say we are excited about this new product and eagerly await to see what it can actually do. An enhanced N.O.V.A. by Gameloft with specfic features developed for the iPad sounds great! There's no doubt that larger maps for real-time strategy games, more physical space to enjoy shooters, or enhanced graphics and processing power for racing games is a good thing.
But for now, I will play the waiting game and proudly jump on the bandwagon if or when it's appropriate to do so. My 2nd Generation iPod Touch continues to be my favorite and the most utilized gadget I have ever purchased. It serves my needs quite well. But a geek at heart, I always keep an eye to the future; letting my imagination run wild with ideas of gizmos we'll be using five years from now. If this new device offers just one thing that takes us closer to that future, then I am totally on board with the iPad...even if I don't plan to buy one.
Awesome post, my sentiments exactly
Thu, 01/28/2010 - 19:47 — adminA very insightful post from Yorkcountyflyer, I think you have mirrored my thoughts on iPad and captured the beliefs of the vast majority of iPhone gamers. How I feel really boils down to a sore sense of disappointment. The iPad could be so good, I think my real problem is with the way that Apple are prepared to absolutely milk it's consumers for all they are worth.
I can't believe that Apple could not of included, many of the features that surely should of been 'top priority'. I am so cynical and it would'nt suprise me if the 3rd gen iPad is sitting in Job's office ready for release in 3 years. Apple are a really great company and I do love their products, but I wish that they would cut out all the 1st, 2nd, 3rd gen garbage and just put out the best they can right from the start.